17 Feb 2017

Where there's muck there's brass

I've been looking at Wirral Council's litter enforcement programme. This has been prompted by several ward residents contacting me claiming aggressive and unfair approaches from the council's enforcement contractor Kingdom Securities.

I have no problem with people being fined for littering but there are legitimate questions to ask about the way this policy is being enforced and whether it possibly has more to do with raising money than tackling the underlying causes of littering.

We know the overwhelming majority of fines relate to cigarette litter. The minutes from the Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committe of November 30th last year confirm this (see page 5). The report states that "80-85% of fines issued were to do with cigarette litter"

The sums raised are substantial with £95,000 raised in a single month according to this report. How much of this leaks out of the borough to Kingdom's owners?

I asked for a break down of fines issued by ward. I didn't quite get that but the information below is, nevertheless, instructive. It shows Birkenhead way ahead of all other areas with over 50% of all the fines issued coming from the Birkenhead area. Wallasey comes next. This means that the overwhelming amount of money raised is coming the poorest parts of the borough. Of course these may also be the areas with the biggest litter problem. But, where is the evidence that fining predominantly low income smokers makes a meaningful contribution to reducing litter on our streets?

The figures below show the number of fines issued for littering in Wirral by Kingdom Resources since its contract with Wirral Council commenced in July 2015. The total number of fines issued is 18,047.

Bebington 535
Bidston 290
Birkenhead 7237
Birkenhead & Tranmere 431
Bromborough 1657
Clatterbridge 5
Claughton 51
Eastham 59
Egremont 1
Frankby 5
Greasby 8
Heswall 278
Hoylake 104
Irby 4
Leasowe 67
Liscard 584
Meols 16
Moreton 808
New Brighton 1549
New Ferry 11
Oxton 18
Pensby 34
Port Sunlight 4
Prenton 196
Rock Ferry 849
Seacombe 316
Spital 2
Thingwall 2
Thurstaston 3
Tranmere 311
Upton 784
Wallasey 1564
West Kirby 244
Woodchurch 20

1 comment:

  1. The notion of "aggressive enforcement" sits well with the career history of Wirral Council's very much IN FAVOUR Martin Liptrot, pretend 'non-political' appointee to the council's image and reputation management programme.

    Non-smoker Liptrot, was once paid handsomely to transform 'steaming cow pats' into objects of desire, concealing the lethal threat of ciggies from third world smokers beneath a cloak of deceit, not only pleasing the crooked execs on the board of Philip Morris, but stuffing his wallet and proving to us he was dangerously unprincipled, cutting a swathe through poverty-stricken third world citizens, creating orphans and shortening the lives of millions of gullible people suffering genuine hardship.

    It's merely the next incarnation of his gruesome career, to hit the pockets and thereby the survival prospects of the already hard-pressed, austerity-clobbered citizens of Birkenhead.

    Frank will be pleased, being a despiser of 'the feckless poor'.


Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.